109,103 concurrent players. Number three on Steam’s Top Sellers chart. Eighty-nine percent positive across more than 19,000 reviews. Windrose, the pirate-themed PvE survival game from developer Kraken Express, is the breakout nobody in the AAA space saw coming — and its own fanbase is already filing bug reports in the review section.

Launched into Early Access on April 14 at $29.99, Windrose bills itself as a PvE survival adventure set in the Age of Piracy. Players build, craft, and explore an open world filled with what the developer describes as “dark secrets,” solo or with friends. Combat is described as “soulslite” — a lighter spin on the punishing ethos behind Dark Souls and its descendants. You command ships. You fight bosses. You plunder treasure. You die. A lot.

The numbers are unambiguous. As of May 1, Windrose is holding at 109,103 concurrent players — up 47.6% from the previous tracking period, according to Steam data. It occupies the #3 spot on Steam’s Top Sellers chart. The review breakdown sits at 17,061 positive against 2,006 negative, for a “Very Positive” aggregate rating.

Open those reviews, though, and a pattern emerges that the aggregate conceals.

“The beginning is rough, you’re weak and even seemingly low level enemies can kill you,” writes one player with 59.2 hours logged. Their advice reads like a survival manual: read guides, upgrade everything, learn to dodge. “You will die a lot so set down tents.” It’s a positive review. They recommend the game. They’re also essentially warning newcomers that the opening act is a wall.

Then there’s ship boarding — theoretically Windrose’s signature thrill, practically its most consistent frustration. “Honestly love the game but omg one of the most important parts needs to be completely rebalanced,” writes a player with 30.7 hours played. They describe methodically clearing eight pirates from an enemy vessel, only to get swarmed by four more, trapped in a corner by what they describe as a bug, killed, and stripped of their inventory. Still a positive review. Still recommended.

And the simplest verdict, from a player with 139.9 hours on record: “This is the best pirate game i’ve ever played, would highly recommend.”

That’s the Windrose paradox in a single page of Steam reviews. Players are wrestling with friction and hitting “recommend” anyway.

The Early Game Wall

The difficulty spike in Windrose’s opening hours isn’t necessarily a design failure. The “soulslite” label is a fair warning. But there’s a difference between challenge that teaches and difficulty that simply blocks. A game whose own fans advise newcomers to consult external guides before the first act has a tutorial problem masquerading as a genre choice. The players pushing through are doing it on stubbornness and wiki pages, not onboarding.

The Boarding Problem

The ship boarding complaints are a different category. These aren’t about difficulty — they’re about systems that don’t function as intended. Players report enemies spawning in unexpected positions, collision glitches trapping them in geometry, and the inventory-loss death penalty turning a single bug into a run-ending setback. In a game whose core fantasy is naval combat and plunder, a malfunctioning boarding mechanic isn’t a rough edge. It’s the central loop, broken.

What Comes Next

Windrose is three weeks into Early Access and the player count is still climbing. The review ratio holds. But Early Access history is full of games that peaked on momentum and bled out on unresolved friction. The difference between a title that sustains six-figure concurrency and one that fades is usually whether the developer patches fast enough to outrun the goodwill clock.

Kraken Express is co-published with Pocketpair Publishing, a Japanese label with infrastructure for sustained development cycles. The community is engaged and specific about what needs to change — the top reviews function as impromptu patch notes. Whether that translates into timely fixes, or whether Windrose becomes another entry in the long catalog of promising Early Access titles that shipped too rough and iterated too slow, is the open question.

109,000 players are already deep into the game. They’ve told the developer exactly what’s wrong, in detail, with timestamps. The next move belongs to Kraken Express.

Sources