17,578 reviews. 88% positive. A dark Arthurian RPG sitting at #10 on Steam’s Top Sellers chart, discounted 35% to $29.24, and one of the most common player assessments boils down to eight words: “If you liked Skyrim you will like this.”

That’s the gravitational pull of Tainted Grail: The Fall of Avalon. Developed by Questline and published by Awaken Realms, this first-person open-world RPG dropped into full release on May 23, 2025, crossed one million units sold by January 2026 according to publisher announcements, and has been building steady momentum ever since. The expansion Sanctuary of Sarras launched in December 2025. The patch notes keep coming. The players keep showing up — 3,935 of them concurrently as of April 19, 2026.

But here’s the tension: the top-voted negative review on Steam isn’t about bugs, balance, or performance. It’s about the fact that, at launch, you couldn’t rebind your left and right mouse buttons. A PC RPG in 2025, shipping without basic input remapping. The player had 1.6 hours on record and requested a refund. “Unacceptable for a 2025 game in my opinion,” they wrote. Questline patched it in version 1.21 on April 2, 2026 — nearly eleven months after full release. The player updated their review, now tagged positive, with cautious optimism: “Maybe they finally fixed it. I’ll…”

Ellipsis and all, that review captures the whole dynamic. Passionate enough fanbase to stick around. Indie enough development to miss fundamentals.

The Skyrim Sized Hole

Let’s be direct about what The Fall of Avalon is and isn’t. IGN’s review — the game sits at 80 on Metacritic — called it out plainly: it “does clearly owe a debt to The Elder Scrolls throughout.” The structure is familiar — first-person combat, open-world exploration, faction quests, a branching storyline. The setting is a grim reimagining of Arthurian myth: King Arthur led his people to Avalon 600 years ago, the land is now consumed by the Wyrdness and the Red Death, and you play as a nameless prisoner who bonds with a fragment of Arthur’s eternal soul. Arthur as your personal Cortana, as IGN put it.

The writing carries real weight. One quest tasks you with convincing a necromancer to abandon their craft. Another sends you to unravel a druidic ritual that turns out to be an elaborate prank. A third has a guard who hates seagulls recruit you for his anti-avian crusade. These are not throwaway tasks — they have texture.

But the cracks are visible. IGN noted that archery is “worthless,” with enemies functioning as massive health sponges early on. Bandits take four or five arrows to the head without flinching. Only two playstyles are viable: heavy or medium armor with melee, or magic with summons. The first ten hours of a roughly fifty-hour campaign are described as rough. The character creator makes everyone look like Play-Doh up close.

The Numbers Behind the Hype

Here’s where the data gets interesting. The Metacritic 80 aligns with user sentiment — 88% positive across 17,578 reviews is strong. But 2,084 negative reviews is not nothing. That’s more dissenting voices than many indie RPGs attract in total.

The 3,935 concurrent players is respectable for a single-player RPG nearly a year after launch, especially during an active sale. It suggests staying power, not a flash spike. The game is charting on both Top Sellers and Specials simultaneously, meaning it’s moving units on discount velocity as much as raw demand.

At $29.24 (down from $44.99), the value proposition is strong for anyone craving a first-person RPG with dark atmosphere and real narrative ambition. The 1.21 patch also added quality-of-life improvements beyond the mouse fix — armor sets for quick loadout switching, widescreen display support, new weapons, enemy placement overhauls, and improved subtitles. Questline is clearly not coasting.

The Verdict on Value

The Skyrim comparison is both The Fall of Avalon’s greatest asset and its heaviest burden. It sets an expectation that the game can’t fully deliver on — Bethesda’s open-world machinery operates at a scale no indie team can match. But what Questline built within those constraints is genuinely impressive: a world with its own identity, combat with real weight, and a narrative that doesn’t flinch from bleakness.

If you’ve been waiting for a reason to dive in, the 35% discount is it. The rough edges haven’t been fully sanded down — they may never be — but eleven months of patches have addressed the most glaring gaps. Including, yes, the ability to rebind your mouse buttons. One of these days we won’t have to celebrate that as an achievement.

Sources