Four user reviews. Zero positives. The top-rated review on Steam opens with a confession that says everything about where Dovetail Games’ reputation sits right now: “Got it to see how bad it really was.”

The Train Sim World 6: Great British Railways Class 802 BMU Add-On launched May 6 at $5.99, and the early returns are brutal. That same reviewer described textures on the paint job that “look like it was done in MS Paint” and said they were pursuing a refund. A second reviewer called the textures blurry and noted the onboard announcements hadn’t changed from existing content — keeping the add-on only because a bundle discount knocked 10% off. A third found brief cause for optimism in improved sounds and suspension before concluding the textures were “just not sharp.” Zero players were concurrent at time of writing.

Forum feedback on Dovetail’s own site echoes the same complaint: the GBR livery looks decent at distance but falls apart up close, with blurry color transitions that one user described as “a 10-15 minute job.”

None of this shocks anyone familiar with the Train Sim World ecosystem. The Big Bois, covering the franchise extensively, called TSW 6 “the definition of a love-hate relationship” — compelling simulation trapped behind what it described as an “abhorrent business model.” The game still runs on Unreal Engine 4. Bugs reported five years ago persist. Dovetail releases a new version annually, which conveniently resets the Steam review score each time. Individual routes cost $39.99. A $6 livery pack with substandard textures fits the pattern.

This is the Train Sim DLC industrial complex in miniature: a dedicated player base that keeps buying despite knowing the quality ceiling, and a publisher that knows it. The bar isn’t on the floor — it’s somewhere in the subsoil. Dovetail hasn’t responded to the texture complaints publicly. Given the track record, a fix arriving any time soon would be the real surprise.

Sources