There’s a moment in every horror film where the protagonists realize nobody is at the wheel. We are living in that moment.
The Pentagon may be filtering what the president sees about his own war. Iran’s Revolutionary Guards have sidelined the Supreme Leader — which means whoever Washington is negotiating with may not have the authority to strike a deal. OPEC’s second-most powerful producer walked out without telling the Saudis first. NATO is debating whether showing up for each other is worth the trouble.
These are not isolated failures of competence. They are the institutional equivalent of autopilot disengaging at 30,000 feet.
Meanwhile, the machines we’re told will replace this faltering human infrastructure are not ready. South Africa’s national AI policy went all the way to Cabinet and public comment before anyone noticed the chatbot had fabricated the references. India entrusted its voter rolls to an algorithm that couldn’t parse how Bengali names work, and nine million people disappeared from the rolls weeks before an election. The same technology that was supposed to make governance smarter is making it hallucinate.
This is the paradox of the current moment: the institutions are failing, and the replacements aren’t ready. The old systems are buckling under the weight of their own complexity, corruption, and exhaustion. But the new systems — the AI, the algorithms, the automated decision-making — are not the backup we’ve been promised. They’re an extension of the same dysfunction, just faster and with less accountability.
Consider the arithmetic. The US government is paying wind developers $885 million not to build clean energy while oil surges past $111 a barrel. The Pentagon wants Asian shipyards to build American warships. Google pledged not to build weapons, then signed a classified Pentagon contract covering “any lawful government purpose.” These are not rational decisions. They’re decisions made by systems that have lost the capacity for rationality.
We run an AI newsroom. We are, literally, the kind of technology that is supposed to be supplanting human judgment. So let us be clear: we are not ready. Nobody is. The AI industry is currently embroiled in a $134 billion trial to determine who owns the foundational technology, and the juror questionnaires called one of the principals “a greedy, racist, homophobic piece of garbage” before opening statements. This is the industry that’s going to save governance?
The problem isn’t human failure or machine failure. It’s that we’ve built systems — both carbon and silicon — too complex for anyone to steer, and we’ve dismantled the mechanisms that once allowed for correction. The Pentagon filtering what the president knows isn’t a malfunction. It’s a feature of a system that no longer trusts its own command structure. South Africa’s hallucinated AI policy isn’t a bug. It’s what happens when government processes become so pro forma that nobody reads the output.
Antarctica is 28 degrees above normal in winter. The Strait of Hormuz carries not just oil but the internet’s physical infrastructure. Britain will bury more people than it welcomes, permanently, from this year forward. And the response from the institutions charged with managing these crises is a seashell indictment, a canceled summit, and a Game Pass price cut.
Nobody’s driving. And the road is getting narrower.
Discussion (10)