Five million copies sold. Seventy thousand Steam reviews. A $3,400 bonus for every employee at developer Pearl Abyss. By every commercial metric, Crimson Desert is a smash.

Then you read the reviews.

“Best game ever sio huge so many options such freedom Amaizing game,” writes one player, 59 hours deep. “BOOOOOORING,” counters another, done after less than five. Both sit prominently on the game’s Steam page. Both are entirely sincere. That gap — between rapture and rage — is the whole story of Crimson Desert right now.

An 87% positive rating across 70,383 reviews sounds like consensus. It isn’t. Dig past the aggregate and you find a player base split not on whether the game is good, but on what “good” even means when the experience swings this wildly.

What the Believers See

The case for Crimson Desert starts with scale. The open world draws from The Witcher 3, Red Dead Redemption 2, and Skyrim — sometimes blatantly, sometimes with genuine flair. A player with over 110 hours logged praised the “Very satisfiying, meaty combat” and an “absolutely huge and gorgeous” world filled with “an insane amount of” content. They’re not alone. Even the game’s harshest critics concede the visuals and performance are remarkable for something this vast.

Pearl Abyss has also earned real goodwill through aggressive patching. The game launched at a brutal 51% positive rating on Steam, according to Forbes, then climbed to 83% within a week and now sits at 87% — 61,078 positive against 9,305 negative as of May 2026. Patch 1.04.00 alone, with notes approaching three thousand words per htxt.co.za, added difficulty settings, new storage options, pets, inventory category tabs, new skills, and scenery improvements.

The commercial payoff has been enormous. Pearl Abyss reportedly sold over five million copies and awarded each of its 733 employees a 5 million Won bonus (roughly $3,400), South Korean outlet MTN reported. South Korean Prime Minister Kim Min-seok publicly praised the game for opening a “new chapter in K-content” and singled out the fact that it was built on Pearl Abyss’s own engine rather than a western one — incorporating Korean elements like taekwondo and Korean cuisine.

What the Doubters Feel

The complaints cluster tight, and they come from players who’ve sunk serious time in.

Combat encounters drag. IGN’s 6/10 review, written across 130 hours of play, noted that fights “almost always go on way too long,” with enemy reinforcements piling in until encounters hit Dynasty Warriors-levels of absurdity. Boss fights wrench players out of a casual action rhythm and into outright soulslike difficulty — multi-phase enemies that feel, in IGN’s words, “extremely out of sync with the rest of the adventure.” Many players found the whiplash more irritating than challenging.

Inventory management was a catastrophe at launch. Limited slots forced players to dump hard-won gear in a game built around collecting cool stuff. Patches have alleviated the worst of it, but the first-impression damage stuck — especially with reviewers working from pre-patch builds.

Then there’s the story. IGN called the dialogue, characters, and narrative “laughably bad.” As IGN put it, the story is “aimless,” the characters are “forgettable,” and the dialogue is “often pretty hard to listen to.” Negative Steam reviews echo the same notes. No patch fixes bad writing.

The $70 Entry Fee

Crimson Desert costs $69.99. That’s the premium shelf — the same tier as Elden Ring and The Last of Us. Charge that much and players arrive with expectations calibrated accordingly. A gorgeous world with janky puzzles, uneven pacing, and a story nobody seems invested in is a tough sell at any price. At $70, it’s an invitation to scrutiny.

The critic-player gap tells the story. Reviewers working with pre-launch builds dealt with worse inventory, barely any fast-travel points, stiffer combat controls, and pre-nerf bosses, as Forbes outlined. Many had just two weeks with a game that takes well over 100 hours to absorb. The result: a 78 Metacritic critic score versus an 8.6 user score. Not a disagreement — a timeline. Pearl Abyss shipped a rough product and sanded it down in real time.

Two Months In, Still Split

Seventy thousand concurrent players. Number nine on Steam’s Top Sellers chart. Five million copies and counting. Crimson Desert is one of the most commercially successful open-world games of 2026 and a Rorschach test for what players actually want from the genre.

The 87% rating is real. So are the thousands who bounced off it hard. Both things are true, and neither side is wrong.

Sources