1.5 million wishlists. Half a million copies in 72 hours. 89% positive across nearly 5,000 Steam reviews. The turn-based strategy franchise that peaked when flip phones were cutting edge just posted launch numbers that make AAA studios look twice.

Heroes of Might and Magic: Olden Era launched into Early Access on April 30, and by any metric that matters, it’s a blowout. Developer Unfrozen and publisher Hooded Horse recouped their entire development budget — roughly $5.5 million, according to Wikipedia — within the first 24 hours, crossing 250,000 sales. By day three, that number had doubled to 500,000, according to TechRaptor.

This is not supposed to happen. Heroes of Might and Magic is a hex-grid turn-based strategy series whose last widely beloved entry, HoMM III, came out in 1999. The franchise spent years being passed between studios like a bad handoff, with no mainline release since 2015’s poorly received HoMM VII. An entire generation of gamers has grown up without ever clicking a hex.

The Right Kind of Nostalgia

The critical consensus is remarkably unified for an Early Access launch. PC Gamer’s Fraser Brown declared that Olden Era “isn’t a reimagining or a divisive reinterpretation, it’s just a brilliant strategy game.” Reviews aggregated by Wikipedia describe “deep and complex gameplay” and note “an overwhelming sense of nostalgia” — the kind that comes from playing something that feels like it never left, not something laboring to remind you of the past.

Part of that credibility comes from the roster. Paul Romero, the composer who defined HoMM’s iconic soundtracks, returned to score Olden Era alongside Cris Velasco (God of War, Mass Effect). Jon Van Caneghem, the original Might and Magic creator, joined Unfrozen as creative advisor in 2026. These aren’t developers chasing nostalgia dollars — they’re the people who built the thing.

The gameplay leans hard into formula, and that’s the point. Six factions — Temple, Necropolis, Grove, Dungeon, Hive, and Schism — each with their own creature roster, building trees, and a new “faction laws” mechanic that adds a layer of strategic customization the series hasn’t seen before. It’s set on the continent of Jadame in the world of Enroth, before the events of the very first Heroes game. A prequel that knows exactly where it came from.

Veterans vs. Newcomers: The Review Split

The Steam review landscape tells two stories.

The top positive review, from a player with 35 hours logged, calls it “just like the old way” and highlights a campaign that’s “interesting with different path to go.” That branching campaign structure — multiple routes through each scenario — is the kind of mechanic that rewards replay and keeps the map fog interesting.

But the top negative review cuts harder, and it comes from a grinder — someone with 200 hours across the demo and Early Access combined, according to their review. “[…] Graphics are a matter of taste, PvE is dead, PvP has potential but i’m afraid they have none capable of balancing all the absurd mechanics they implemented in this game. […]” That’s not a drive-by hater. That’s someone who stress-tested the systems and found where they buckle.

The visual style is the flashpoint. Olden Era doesn’t chase photorealism — it leans into a look that evokes the sprite-based charm of HoMM III, updated but unmistakably retro. For veterans, that’s the whole point. For players raised on Total War: Warhammer’s cinematic battles, it reads as dated. The 526 negative reviews — 11% of the total — cluster around this fault line.

The $40 Early Access Question

At $39.99, Olden Era is priced like a finished game. For an Early Access title, that’s a bet. Hooded Horse and Unfrozen are wagering that the content available at launch justifies full-price admission, and the 89% approval rating suggests most buyers agree. The game is also available on PC Game Pass, though Microsoft’s platform doesn’t share player counts.

But Early Access is a marathon. The veteran reviewer’s concerns about PvP balance and PvE depth aren’t theoretical — they’re exactly the kind of issues that get patched into respectability over a year of updates or calcify into permanent complaints.

What Comes Next

Olden Era sits at #6 on Steam’s Top Sellers chart as of mid-May, with a concurrent player count hovering near 38,000. Its all-time peak hit 60,000, according to TechRaptor. Add in the Game Pass audience, and the real player base is substantially larger than Steam alone suggests.

For a franchise that spent a decade in the wilderness, the question was always whether anyone still cared. The numbers answer that definitively. Whether Unfrozen can carry this momentum through Early Access and into a proper 1.0 release — that’s the campaign that matters now.

Sources